Sunday, March 15, 2009

"The State of the Black Union" sponsor is sued by the NAACP


While I was reading over the lawsuit filed by the NAACP for predatory lending practices, my eyes kept returning to Wells Fargo. My something-smells-funny nose kept sniffing until I looked across my desk and saw the program guide from the recent State of the Black Union (SOTBU). In large font was the Wells Fargo logo, title sponsor of the event. I wondered if the NAACP had any dialogue with Tavis Smiley prior to the lawsuit being filed. The bank that is being sued for institutionalized racism sponsors a think tank for black folks. (You cannot make this stuff up.)

Wells Fargo has sponsored the SOTBU for several years. SOTBU was the brainchild of Tavis Smiley and birthed from his weekly commentary on the Tom Joyer Morning Show. Tavis Smiley quit the TJMS in April of last year and moved on to other projects that needed more of his attention. One of those projects is to hold President Obama accountable for his political record and campaign promises made on the campaign trail as outlined in his recent book.

From his book:
“During the run-up to the 2008 presidential election, while I was still the resident political commentator on the Tom Joyner Morning Show, I caused quite a stir among the listeners, who are largely African-American, by insisting that we hold then Senator Barack Obama accountable for both his political record and his campaign promises. I wasn’t singling him out, but rather applying the same standard to him that we should apply to all.

I feel now, as I did then, that it is our responsibility as engages citizens to expect now-President Barack Obama to live up to the promises that made him an appealing candidate… As Martin Luther King, Jr.’s Letter from Birmingham Jail reminds us, ‘Human progress never rolls in on wheels of inevitability; it comes from the tireless efforts of men willing to be coworkers with God, and without this hard work, time itself becomes an ally of the forces of social stagnation.’

So, let us take Dr. King’s lead… and go forth and make real the promise of our democracy.”
-- Excerpted from the Foreword (pages xii-xiii)

The SOTBU website states "Some of the most influential thinkers, entertainers, and political leaders of our time gather each year to discuss the State of the Black Union during Black History Month. Presented annually in February by Tavis Smiley Presents, the symposium was created to educate, enlighten and empower America by bringing people together and engaging them in thoughtful dialogue, leading the way to constructive action."


The man who has written a book titled Accountable, has accepted sponsorship for years from a bank that is being accused of forcing blacks into subprime mortgages while whites with identical qualifications got lower rates. Class-action lawsuits were filed against Wells Fargo and HSBC in federal court in Los Angeles. Los Angeles was also the host city for the State of the Black Union.

My words may anger some but this is equivalent to a child molester opening up a neighborhood daycare center. It is this type of irony in the black community by leaders and organizations that keeps folks from getting ahead. "Leaders" play nice and accept money from the very organizations that causes the most harm and perpetuate media stereotypes. This happens in many communities but it is perverse in the communities of color.

Does this means Tavis is going to turn his journalistic intuition on Wells Fargo and hold them accountable? I hope so. These are serious charges being leveled at a time when banks that are behaving badly are receiving TARP bailouts. Is he going to compile the number of loans that were given to blacks vs. whites and research the information and give it to the board of directors of Wells Fargo? Will he ask for their resignations? Now that is taking action. Will he help them be a better bank by helping them exam how they conduct business with people of color? Will he turn down their sponsorship next year and take their logo off his website with a link to their mortgage department? That would be worthy of an NAACP Image Award! Is this not what several of the panelist ask often when others accept sponsorship or advertisement from organizations that do not toe the line when allegations or perceived racist misconduct occur? All the time.

Tavis has always asked his listeners and viewers to be watchful and test everything and everyone. How did Wells Fargo allege predatory practices get around Tavis who would not allow then Senator Obama to campaign without a thorough scrutiny of the issues and his character? President Obama who has been on the national political scene less than ten years is being exam microscopically by Tavis. While SOTBU, Tavis and the same panelists year after year have held meetings with very loud megaphones on radio and television turned blind eyes to the practices of Wells Fargo and others. Practices that have gone on much longer than President Obama has been in the White House according to the time line stated in the NAACP lawsuit.

Many of the speakers at Tavis'2009 SOTBU event were the same faces sitting in the audience for the 2009 NAACP Image Awards. The award show was televised on the Fox Network, which was the subject of a boycott. (You cannot make this up.) Some body's PR people are not talking to the other folks' legal department and the legal department is surely not talking to the marketing representatives. In the fragile world of sponsorship and raising dollars for mega events to show accountability, this sounds like a church split or at the very least biting the hands that sponsor/televise your events. This is enough to leave one confused and bewildered.

Before I am accused of being a hater, my beloved grandfather started the NAACP in our town in Mississippi. He stepped out on faith and held meetings when it was considered a death wish to do so. He stood by his principles and gained the respect of everyone including his critics. Not one sponsor paid for meetings that enlightened, encouraged and empowered his fellow man. He received numerous awards and accolades for his work in the field of civil rights. Daddy received letters from Presidents, Governors and other notables as well as those that made a difference that wore no title at all. "Fair is fair," he said often. "Don't have a rule for one that you can't have for the other," would be his cry. Daddy's motivation for working hard to ensure others had the right to vote was based on his love for mankind. Daddy was all about fair play, even if it meant ticking off folks who sat on panels. (I learned from the best.)

I like Tavis and his work. My critique is exactly what Tavis asks of the public. I will be the first to say he has done much for many. But elusive sponsorship dollars have a way of making folks look the other way. Demands cannot be made of one and not hold everyone else to the same standards. That include corporations who sponsor think tanks regarding accountability. As "engaged citizens", we need to hold each other accountable, seek transparency and make sure we are doing due diligence with everyone. Since Tavis has rightly challenged everyone to hold our President accountable for promises made, let us make sure Tavis does not stop with the President who has resided at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue less than six months.

I do hope that Tavis get back to us with any research on Wells Fargo and the outcome of the lawsuit by the NAACP. I think his findings should be included in the next State of the Black Union or at the next NAACP Image Award Show. I suggest getting Jon Stewart from The Daily Show to be host. Now that I would pay to sponsor, no questions asked.

11 comments :

Franz said...

I honestly believe Tavis Smiley had anyway of knowing that wells fargo was conducting business like that with black patrons. It does make since if it was wells fargo true intentions of making mint off of african americans to be market themselves to that distict population. Like u said a child molestor's dream job would be a daycare because it puts them contact with so many children! It will be interesting to see what Tavis Smiley

realitygirl2 said...

Thank you for connecting this info for me. Sorry I did not use my independence to see what is before citizens of the USA. Also, Tavis made statements that implied outrageous racism when he asked the panel "How will we dance..." to get the President to listen to black Americans. The guy is extremely embarassing. Bill and Hillary Clinton aired their racism in a very open forum. Tavis continues to hold black Americans in a slave state by is open statements of racism against the highest black leader in this nation. He continues to stoop and bow to those persons who hold all blacks in slavery. I wish that he would stop trying to sabotage this administration. Perhaps he is envious because he tried to climb to the top with corporate America and Hillary but Pres. Obama has the intelligence above Tavis, Wachovia, and Hillary to make this a better country.

J. Monroe said...

I had been listening to some of the comments that Tavis had for the President while he was campaigning. I'm glad you caught this little oversight and wonder if Tavis will address this issue. Before a lawsuit was out against Wells Fargo everyone knew they were crooks. Thank you, thank you, thank you and I will like to see the developments to this story. Please keep us posted on the outcome of Tavis' reaction.

Pamela Lyn said...

Thanks for sharing your insights.

I was also bothered by the ExxonMobil sponsorship. In spite of the fact that the Exxon Valdez oil spill did untold damage to the Alaskan coastline and, the oil giant raked in record breaking profits in 2008, last year the US Supreme Court reduced the $2.5 billion punitive damages award against Exxon to $507.5 million.

So it seems that the last corporation that should be prominently featured during on conference that emphasized accountability should be Exxon.

Renee said...

I am not the least bit surprised to find out that he went with this kind of sponsorship. Tavis Smiley is not about promoting the black community he is about promoting himself. I have had a long dislike of that snake like man. This was an excellent catch. You can bet he will try to ignore it in the hopes that people forget what he did. He very rarely answers his critics.

Black girl with long hair said...

this is a GREAT post... i actually first saw it on the black snob. but yeh, tavis took a really hard line on barack obama... which i kinda respected. but now i'm not so sure.

the sad thing is that major companies probably view endorsement as a STRATEGY to get black activists to shut up.

so sad that black people can be so mesmerized by money — the root of the majority of our evils.

Miriam said...

I got to your blog from Aunt Jemima's link. Thanks for explaining that whole subject.

Divalocity said...

One day, I was passing by the book section of our local WAL-MART and I saw what I thought was an image of President Obama on the cover of a book. I stop and picked up the book and threw it back down, sure it was an image of the president but the author was Tavis Smiley and I no longer read anything written by him.

He is just like a lot of other people who are attempting to cash in on the presidents popularity and imagery. After 10 years, I wonder have they thought has anything changed for the very people they claim to help? We don't need to talk any more about the dissolution of our problems, it's going to take real action.

Tavis is not going to cut the ties with Wells Fargo because events like his need big money backing and of course I’m sure he earns an income from this partnership also.

Virgil said...

I have been thinking the same thing for years. Think about it after last year SOTBU Tavis is still grinding on that ax he just want let go!

blackgirlinmaine said...

Bravo, I agree that this situation is very much like a known child molestor opening up a daycare center.

I got to be honest, I don't have much love for Mr. Smiley, over the years I have become convinced he is more about lifting up Tavis rather than lifting up Black folks.

I am not Star Jones said...

Clearly, Mr. Smiley suffers from an extreme case of cognitive dissonance. He is not the first nor will he be the last.

But I wonder who will be his Tavis Smiley following his every move demanding accountability?